Showing posts with label mode. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mode. Show all posts

Monday, 6 October 2025

Multimodality, Reposting, and Superdiversity: Descriptive Cataloguing Without Functional Integration

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 131):
While not our direct focus here, it should also be noted that social media communication is multimodal in nature, with visual media such as static images, GIFs, and digital stickers regularly functioning as moves within the type of exchange structure allowed by the particular digital platform (Jovanovic & Van Leeuwen, 2018). Processes of reposting material across platforms are also an important form of meaning-making (Adami, 2014) and this type of re-articulation complicates what is meant by dialogue and exchange. Social media communication also tends to be highly multilingual and multicultural (Bouvier, 2015), another dimension beyond the scope of the present work and which is deserving of attention given the great potential for translanguaging (Zhao & Flewitt, 2020) and cross-cultural affiliation in 'superdiverse' multiplatform environments (Leppänen, Peuronen, & Westinen, 2018).


ChatGPT Comments:

This paragraph gestures to significant phenomena in contemporary digital communication—multimodality, reposting, and linguistic/cultural diversity—but does so without engaging with systemic-functional principles. While it is true that images, GIFs, stickers, and reposting function as semiotic moves, the authors do not specify how these modes and actions are integrated into a stratified account of meaning. There is no modelling of how visual or gestural resources interact with interpersonal and ideational meanings, leaving the account descriptive rather than analytic.

Similarly, the discussion of multilingualism and superdiverse contexts introduces rich sociolinguistic variables, yet the authors explicitly place them “beyond the scope of the present work.” This rhetorical hedging acknowledges the importance of translanguaging and cross-cultural affiliation, but it also highlights a limitation: the current chapter cannot yet show how tenor, field, and mode are realised when multiple semiotic and linguistic repertoires intersect.

Finally, the treatment of reposting and re-articulation as complicating dialogue is accurate, but the conceptualisation remains thin. In SFL terms, the problem is not simply that dialogue is complicated; it is that the semiotic orchestration of interpersonal meaning across platforms requires formal modelling of the resources that enact alignment, evaluation, and affiliation. Without such modelling, the discussion risks remaining a cataloguing of phenomena rather than a functional analysis.

In sum, the paragraph successfully signals avenues for future research, but offers little in the way of systemic-functional insight in its own right.

Sunday, 5 October 2025

Dialogic, Multilogic, and Ambient Affiliation: Conceptual Variety vs. Systemic Modelling

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 130-1):

As we saw in the previous chapter when dealing with monologue, direct interaction is not a prerequisite for “communion of feeling” (Firth, 1964, p. 112). Dialogic exchanges are possible on social media platforms, although "the unfolding is more often a ‘multilogue’ of simultaneous voices that, at times, can seem more a of cacophony than a conversation" (Zappavigna, 2018, p. 44). Early research into computer-mediated communication focused on exploring the differences between synchronous and asynchronous communication. However, a more pertinent variable from the perspective of tenor is whether the interaction is dialogic or multilogic (many to many) and whether it also affords ambient affiliation. In other words, an important dimension is whether direct exchanges between participants are a prerequisite for interactive social bonding or whether communion can occur through other means. These include the coordination possibilities afforded by features of digital environments that support different ways of creating connection, both on a localized and aggregated levels. Concepts that have been used to study how such groupings are formed discursively online include online affinity spaces (Gee, 2005) and conviviality (Varis & Blommaert, 2015), as well as the kind of ambient affiliation we will consider in this chapter.


ChatGPT Comments:

This paragraph gestures towards important issues but remains imprecise at the theoretical level. The appeal to Firth’s “communion of feeling” provides a historical anchor, yet it is mobilised only rhetorically; the term is neither re-specified nor related to tenor as a system. Instead, it serves as a way to sidestep the real analytical problem: how collective affect and alignment are instantiated semiotically in mediated environments.

The proposed variable of “dialogic versus multilogic” interaction risks falling into the same typological trap as the previous paragraph. Systemic-functional theory demands that options be modelled in terms of system networks, yet “dialogue,” “multilogue,” and “ambient affiliation” are invoked as descriptive categories without integration into a systemic model. This results in a proliferation of terms that orbit around the problem without structuring it.

Similarly, the list of conceptual imports—“affinity spaces,” “conviviality,” “ambient affiliation”—reflects eclectic borrowing rather than theoretical consolidation. These constructs, drawn from disparate traditions, are simply juxtaposed without clarifying how they correspond to SFL’s account of meaning potential. The notion of “ambient affiliation” is announced as the chapter’s focus, but its relationship to field, tenor, and mode is not specified, leaving unclear whether it is an expansion, a sub-type, or an orthogonal dimension.

The net effect is that the paragraph substitutes conceptual variety for systemic precision. It raises useful questions—whether bonding requires direct exchange, how communion may be mediated—but does not provide the categories needed to address them within SFL’s framework.

Saturday, 4 October 2025

Multilogue and Platform Capitalism: Limits of Typological Description

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 130):

Up until this point we have largely been concerned with how social relations are negotiated in monologue and dialogue. But in contemporary society there are many ways in which we enact these relations without necessarily interacting directly with other people – via broadcast and digital media. Multilogue communication has become an important feature of contemporary social life due to the expansion of "semiotic technologies" (technologies for making meaning) (Zhao, Djonov, & van Leeuwen, 2014) affording one-to-many and many-to-many communication. This kind of communication has engendered 'status-updating' and various kinds of comment genres whereby people share their experiences and opinions with others in real-time on social media. The expanded communicative affordances offered by such digital platforms have augmented the ways in which people can interact, both in terms of increasing the range of connection possible and reducing the extent to which direct interaction is required for tenor to be negotiated (Zappavigna, 2018; Zappavigna & Martin, 2018a). At the same time, social media platforms operate by the essential logic inherent in digital platform economies – namely that of aiming to profit financially from the ways in which people connect with one another. They thus advance a capitalist agenda that has pervaded the last few centuries towards what is perhaps its maximal endgame – i.e., our very social relations are now being mined for profit.



ChatGPT Comments:

This paragraph attempts to bring digital communication into the orbit of SFL’s account of tenor by invoking “multilogue” and “semiotic technologies.” Yet the treatment is conceptually shallow. First, the distinction between dialogue, monologue, and multilogue is offered descriptively rather than systemically. In SFL, negotiation of social relations requires modelling as options within a network; here, however, we are given only a typological list. “Multilogue” is introduced as if naming were theorisation, when in fact the phenomenon remains unmodelled.

Second, the invocation of “semiotic technologies” draws on Zhao et al. without any effort to integrate the notion into the SFL stratified framework. Technologies may be affordances for meaning, but the question for SFL is how those affordances restructure the organisation of tenor as a system. That is left unaddressed. Instead, the analysis slides into an anecdotal catalogue of “status-updating” and “comment genres,” with no attempt to specify what system(s) these instantiate or expand.

Finally, the pivot to platform capitalism—while not incorrect in its sociological diagnosis—remains grafted onto the discussion rather than integrated into the theoretical account. To say that social relations are “mined for profit” is not to explain how tenor is reconfigured under these conditions. The effect is a layering of political critique atop a descriptive typology, rather than a systemic-functional analysis.

In short, the paragraph offers an important problem—the reorganisation of social relations through digital platforms—but fails to develop the categories needed to model it.