Wednesday, 22 October 2025

GIFs and the Perils of Overinterpretation: Questioning Assumed Interpersonal Impact

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 141):

Perhaps the strongest staking resource in (39) is a GIF. This GIF is a snippet from an episode of at the conclusion of the fifth season of the TV series 'Game of Thrones' in which Cersei, the queen mother of the realm, is subjected to a humiliating punishment due to her numerous transgressions (which included engaging in an adulterous relationship with her twin brother). The penalty for this behaviour involved the removal of her hair and a naked walk through the streets, where she is forced to confront her subjects who taunt her with jeers, shouting 'shame!'. These cries are visibly rendered in the GIF through the overlayed text. Behind her is a woman ringing a bell and chanting the same words. The perpetual looping that is inherent in GIFs and animated stickers appears to amplify their interpersonal significance and require their recipients to interpret and respond to them in ways that are nuanced and contextually sensitive. In (39) the GIF serves as a kind of visual interpersonal theme which emphasises the shame at the heart of the confession genre that is leveraged in the body of the post to raise the stakes of the everyday experiences of motherhood expressed by the user.



ChatGPT Comments:

While the authors provide a detailed description of the GIF and its narrative source, their analysis makes a conceptual leap that is not fully justified. They claim that the GIF “appears to amplify their interpersonal significance” and functions as a “visual interpersonal theme” that raises the stakes of the post. However, this interpretation assumes that all recipients of the post will decode the GIF in the same way and that its cultural reference (Cersei’s punishment) maps directly onto the user’s motherhood confession.

A critical point is that this reading conflates semiotic affordance with interpreted meaning: while GIFs are certainly rich in potential interpersonal effect, the interpersonal significance is not inherent in the GIF itself but is context-dependent and variable across audiences. The authors could have been more cautious in framing this as a probabilistic or contingent effect rather than a categorical one.

In short, the description of the GIF is solid, but the interpretive claim about its effect on interpersonal stakes overextends beyond what the data can reliably support.

Tuesday, 21 October 2025

Confession as Category Error: The Moral Overcoding of Maternal Expression

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 140):

Unsurprisingly, given #momguilt was part of the corpus selection criteria, self-targeted upscaled rejection was one of the most common patterns implicated in raising stakes about the extent to which the users felt that they were good mothers. However, this rendering pattern was highly sensitive to other dimensions in the posts, most significantly the use of humour, and could be used in both raising and lowering the interpersonal stakes of the meaning put at risk. A simple example in the corpus is intensification of self-directed rejection regarding the user's self-perceived capacity to act as a good caregiver which they express in terms of affect.

(36) [Name] stopped sleeping well recently & I got super upset with her because of it & after our visit to the ER Monday, had our follow up today to find out she has a double ear infection. & I feel like the worst person alive . #MomGuilt
(37) Legit feel like the worst mom in the world when I have to wake my daughter up to take her to my MIL so I can go to work #momguilt

(38) Summer: when you feel like the worst parent ever cause all your kid wants to do it play with you & you decided to have a career #momguilt

These kinds of admissions and negative self-assessments were part of an ongoing motif in the corpus of confession, whereby mothers admit the various ways in which they have failed to be a 'good mom'. Framing their sharing of everyday observations about the activity of motherhood as a confession raises the stakes – the confessional is after all an inherently consequential genre where for some 'believers' the fate of an immortal soul hangs in the balance.


ChatGPT Comments:

This passage exemplifies the authors’ recurring misrecognition of affective discourse as moral ritual. Their claim that expressions of maternal guilt on social media constitute a “motif of confession” is not an empirical finding but a projection of a theological template onto everyday discourse. The “confessional” is treated as if it were an inherent semiotic genre rather than an analytic imposition—one that carries with it a pre-modern hierarchy of sin, guilt, and absolution.

The women’s posts are not confessions but construals of situated affect: relational calibrations of care, exhaustion, and accountability within an overdetermined social frame. To cast them as “confession” is to re-encode these construals in the very ideology of moral purification that the posts implicitly contest. The social function of #momguilt is not penitence but collective recognition—a distributed negotiation of impossible standards of care. By forcing these utterances into the logic of “raising the stakes” through “confession,” the authors mistake the interpersonal circulation of empathy for the reproduction of moral order.

The irony is sharp: their analysis performs the same disciplinary gesture it claims to describe. What they call “confession” is not a genre of guilt but a social affordance for reclaiming agency in the face of systemic demand. 

Monday, 20 October 2025

The Exhaustion of Stakes: When Intensification Becomes Performance

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 139-40):

Intensification via resources such as the modal adjuncts was frequently used in the corpus to raise the stakes of the users' attitudes toward the proposition or situation being described, in terms of possibility, probability, necessity, or obligation. For example, 'always' in (33)- (35) raises the stakes of the meaning by presenting the situations described as intractable and ongoing.

(33) You guys moms guilt is so real.. No matter what I do I always question whether or not I made the right decisions.
(34) Im SURE it’s not just me but as a mom I ALWAYS feel like I should be doing more or that I didn’t do enough before I went to work. #momguilt

(35) I always feel guilty going to the #spa when my family is free to hang. #momguilt #lifestyle

In these examples the intensification also raises the stakes by stressing that the users are engaging in a behaviour that contravenes a set of assumed values about good motherhood. These examples also illustrate that, like scoping, stakes often runs as a prosody through texts and is realised through an array of different language resources – in the first tweet above, for instance, it is realised through so real, No matter what I do and I always question…


ChatGPT Comments:

The authors’ appeal to “raising the stakes” through intensification misrecognises what is actually happening in these posts. The repeated always, so real, and no matter what I do are not mechanisms for staking a proposition within a social semiotic field — they are symptoms of a discourse that has already collapsed into performative exhaustion. The mothers are not negotiating risk; they are reaffirming a structurally predetermined guilt economy in which the very act of self-reference is already subordinated to communal expectation.

By interpreting intensification as a means of “raising stakes,” Doran, Martin & Zappavigna mistake the automation of affect for its escalation. These users are not heightening the value of propositions; they are tracing the prosodic contour of an internalised injunction. The “stakes” do not rise — they circulate, forming a feedback loop in which self-blame is semantically recharged through the very linguistic resources meant to express relief.

Thus, what the authors take as evidence of “prosodic attitudinal flow” is more precisely the semiotic residue of value reproduction: the rhythmic recycling of guilt as a form of social synchronisation. Always doesn’t raise the stakes — it sustains the circuit.

Sunday, 19 October 2025

When Calibration Pretends to Be Neutral

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 139):

By way of probing staking further, we might ask how much of an issue it might be if a tendered meaning were rejected. In the case of (31) this involves considering how controversial it would be for another user to reply that in fact mothers tending to their own needs is a selfish act worthy of shame. This would be a high stakes rendering within online communities of mothers, but potentially relatively low stakes in other communities such as the 'manoverse' of toxic masculinity, where denigrating women is a shared exercise. Since answering the question involves fine-tuning levels of attitude, GRADUATION is a resource which is frequently implicated in staking both tendered and rendered meanings. For instance, (32) deploys graduation resources (bold) to emphasise the magnitude of emotion that the mother expresses about leaving her child and thus raise the stakes.

(32) Having major mom guilt today... Leaving my little to go away for the weekend is killing me. #momguilt


ChatGPT Comments

This one’s dense with ideological presuppositions masquerading as “fine-tuning.” 

What is striking in this passage is the way GRADUATION is treated as a scalar mechanism for “fine-tuning” affect, while the ontological cut it enacts is left uninterrogated. The authors’ premise — that “raising the stakes” is a matter of degree rather than of construal — reifies affective intensity as an intrinsic property of the utterance, rather than as a relational alignment between construals.

The language of “high stakes” and “low stakes” performs a covert normalisation of community-specific value gradients as if they were empirical facts. To say that denigrating women is merely “low stakes” in certain online spaces is to confuse social saturation with ontological neutrality: the widespread construal of an evaluative stance does not render it less meaningful, only differently aligned. The “manoverse” is not a domain where value loses intensity; it is a domain where intensity is differently organised.

By attributing these contrasts to “levels of attitude,” the passage converts ideological formation into affective amplitude — the political becomes scalar. GRADUATION thus operates here not as a resource for mapping semiotic tension, but as a theoretical anaesthetic that flattens difference into measurable magnitude. The analytic posture of “probing staking further” becomes an alibi for preserving the very moral geometry it claims to examine.

Saturday, 18 October 2025

The Shout of the System: When Paralinguistic Emphasis Masquerades as Social Risk

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 139):

In the case of motherhood guilt, a lot of staking work is undertaken against a background of oriented and positioned meanings about what it is to be a 'good' mother. An example is (31) which likens, through a token-value relation, self-care to the state of being a good mom.

(31) I always forget that self care DOES equate to being a good mom. #momguilt #iForget #poor[Name] #moremomguilt

The ALL CAPS font (DOES) raises the stakes of the proposition by both acting as a form of emphasis and as a paralinguistic shouting token. The move to raise the stakes also suggests a direct challenge (rejection and opposition) to an implicated perspective – that is, that a bad mother takes care of their own needs. The linguistic intensification ('always') also raises the stakes of the user's confession ('I always forget...'). Both instances of escalating stakes function in conjunction with the string of hashtags that explicitly mark the relevant values under scrutiny – the guilt or not of mothers and whether or not they remember their place in the order of things.


ChatGPT Comments:

This passage exposes a recurrent problem in the authors’ treatment of “staking”: the conflation of semiotic intensity with social consequence. The example of (31) is described as raising “stakes” through ALL CAPS and linguistic intensifiers such as always. Yet these are resources of graduation—they scale affect or engagement within language, not risk within context. To equate emphasis with consequence is to confuse the semiotic amplification of commitment with the social evaluation of value.

In SFL, stakes—if construed as part of tenor—must refer to shifts in the relative social significance of a move within a given community’s network of meanings. A proposition typed in capitals does not become high-stakes by orthographic volume alone; it becomes high-stakes only if it threatens or reinforces the value structure of the field or community in which it circulates. In (31), the risk lies not in the typography but in the challenge to normative ideals of maternal self-abnegation.

By treating paralinguistic shouting as a proxy for social risk, the analysis collapses the distinction between graphological realisation and contextual enactment. What’s at stake is not how loudly something is said, but what order of meaning that utterance contests. 

Friday, 17 October 2025

High Stakes and Shifting Grounds: When Tenor Becomes Institutional Loyalty

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 139):

Staking describes the resources that adjust the relative risk of a proposition or proposal, making it more or less consequential. The risk is relative in the sense that it works in concert with the constellations of values that are always in play within the discourse of any particular community and which may shift abruptly or evolve over time. The tendering of a proposition or proposal will be more or less disruptive to these constellations. For example, if within the SFL community, one was to reject Halliday’s work, it would be tantamount to rejecting the SFL community itself. On the other hand if one were to reject the work of one of the authors of this book, it would not necessarily have the same effect (though it would have a larger or smaller effect depending on which author you are rejecting). In the constellation surrounding SFL, Halliday is very high stakes.


ChatGPT Comments:

This passage attempts to introduce staking as a system for describing the relative “risk” associated with meaning in discourse. However, it immediately anchors that risk not in the semantics of discourse but in the social politics of academic communities — in this case, the institutional hierarchy of Systemic Functional Linguistics. The example of “rejecting Halliday’s work” equated with “rejecting the SFL community” does not merely illustrate the concept; it inadvertently collapses the distinction between tenor as semiotic context and tenor as sociological affiliation.

Within canonical SFL, tenor is a variable of context realised by interpersonal semantics. It describes the relations enacted through meaning, not the institutional relations maintained through allegiance. By using “risk” in this way, the authors conflate the semantic system with the social system, translating the modulation of interpersonal meaning (e.g. commitment, obligation, affective alignment) into the sociological maintenance of community identity.

The analogy therefore re-grounds staking not in the grammar of interpersonal exchange, but in disciplinary loyalty. Rather than clarifying how meanings scale in value, commitment, or investment within discourse, the passage reduces staking to an index of orthodoxy — a measure of how far a speaker can deviate from institutional norms without being excommunicated. The result is that risk is treated as reputational rather than semiotic.

A theoretically coherent treatment of staking would instead keep the focus within the discourse semantic plane: on how evaluation is intensified or mitigated, how commitment is modulated through ENGAGEMENT, or how alignment is negotiated in APPRAISAL. These are the mechanisms by which stakes are raised or lowered within the meaning system, rather than within the discipline. 

Thursday, 16 October 2025

Metadata or Metadiscourse? The Semiotic Misfire of the Hashtag

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 138):

With respect to some of the novel features of social media multilogue, as a form of social metadata hashtags have the general capacity to bridge between individual and collective experience with implications for scoping. For example, in (30) individual feelings are linked to broader experiences across the social network.

(30) I feel like a bad mom but I totally brought C into bed with me last night...I was just so tired and I know he sleeps better and falls back to sleep faster next to me. It was only for 4hrs but I still feel the mom guilt. #secretsmomskeep #momguilt

In this post the source of the rendering is the author of the post, individualised as I, but this experience is collectivised through the hashtag #secretsmomskeep. This allows the mother to turn her specific experience into a generalisable truth that can be shared more widely. In addition to targeting the preceding verbiage as an evaluative metacomment, the hashtag links the particular secrets shared in the body of the post to other potential posts sharing the same hashtag. We can also interpret this as having a convoking function, calling together other mothers who have secrets to share using the same tag.


ChatGPT Comments:

Doran, Martin, and Zappavigna attribute to hashtags a “capacity to bridge between individual and collective experience,” positioning them as a kind of “social metadata” that shapes scoping. While intuitively appealing, this account slips across strata in ways that blur the line between contextual affordance and discourse semantic function.

In systemic functional terms, scope is not a resource of the digital medium but a meaning construed within language—a semantic pattern of collectivisation or individuation. Hashtags, however, operate primarily as indexical devices within the architecture of the platform: they categorise posts, connect them via algorithmic indexing, and create retrievability across user-generated content. When a user adds a tag such as #secretsmomskeep, they are not “linguistically collectivising” per se, but rather activating an infrastructural mechanism that can facilitate collectivisation discursively. The bridge between individual and collective thus occurs through an interplay of strata—contextual affordance (platform architecture) and discourse semantic construal (collectivising language)—not through the tag itself.

Moreover, by describing the hashtag as “targeting the preceding verbiage as an evaluative metacomment,” the authors treat it as if it were an in-text appraisal token. In practice, the hashtag’s evaluative force is usually inferential, dependent on platform conventions and communal uptake. It is not the tag’s inherent semantics but its metadiscursive circulation—the recursive indexing of meaning across texts—that collectivises affect and stance.

In short, hashtags do not “bridge” individual and collective meanings in themselves; they infrastructurally scaffold the conditions under which such bridging becomes semiotically possible. Treating them as discourse semantic resources within tenor collapses that distinction and risks mistaking algorithmic collectivity for semiotic community. 

Wednesday, 15 October 2025

The Geography of Misreading: When Spatialisation Becomes Demography

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 138):

Spatialisation was much less common in the corpus, most likely due to the ambient nature of the communication rendering geographical co-location is less of a shared variable. The US spelling of ‘mom’ in the #momguilt hashtag, probably meant that the data tended to be produced by people residing in the US, as (27) suggests.

(27) American moms: let's stop feeling guilty and start getting mad [URL to article in the Guardian with same title] #MothersDay #motherhood #momguilt #workersrights #paygap #femalelabor #equalpay

Some spatialisation resources acted to introduce a political inflection to the variety of

#momguilt at stake, both sourcing and convoking to a specified collective community.

(28) Thanks to @motherwellmag for re-posting this piece. We need to take care of ourselves and our country at the same time. #momguilt [embedded post: We are already made to feel guilty, as mothers, about so many things, we musn’t add political activism to the list. [URL]]

(29) A lot of horrible stuff exists in the world.. In this country thankfully not the case (islamophobic attacks against kids ). AND there is no oppressing a 4 year old - because if she wants a sparkly clip or a sparkly headscarf.. that 4 year old is getting it - #momguilt


ChatGPT Comments: 

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna’s discussion of spatialisation reveals a familiar but persistent slippage in the modelling of context: the conflation of contextual variables with empirical correlates. Here, spatialisation is treated primarily in terms of where participants are located in the physical world (“people residing in the US”), rather than how spatial relations are semiotically construed within texts. This represents a drift from context as culture potential to context as metadata.

From a systemic functional perspective, spatialisation—if theorised as a contextual parameter—should describe how meanings are organised around the construal of place relations: how proximity, distance, directionality, or co-presence are mobilised as resources for interpersonal alignment or ideational positioning. By contrast, the authors’ treatment frames spatialisation as an empirical descriptor of the data source (“US spelling of ‘mom’”) rather than a variable of contextual meaning. This renders “space” as a sociological filter rather than a semiotic dimension.

Even the examples given—posts involving U.S. motherhood and national identity—suggest that the genuinely interesting question lies not in geography per se, but in the semiotic spatialisation of belonging: how motherhood and national affiliation are aligned or disaligned through language. Yet the analysis does not pursue this. “This country,” in example (29), could have opened an inquiry into the interplay between symbolic space (nationhood) and the affective space of parenting—how “our country” functions as a collective spatial metaphor that intersects with guilt, care, and identity. Instead, the focus remains at the level of demographic inference.

The result is that spatialisation risks becoming a descriptive convenience rather than a theoretically integrated category. Rather than extending the tuning model into a spatial dimension of contextual meaning, it momentarily collapses into corpus annotation—a return to data geography rather than discourse semantics.

Tuesday, 14 October 2025

Scoping the Collective: Stratal Misalignment in the Treatment of Scoping

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 137-8):

As mentioned in Section 5.4, membership categorisation tends to be a scoping resource since in order to point out to whom a meaning is relevant, a person or group needs to be identified or at least implicated through some meaning that activates relevant associations. Less explicit collectivising can also occur through resources that invoked putative others. For instance, we or us were quite frequent in the corpus and this choice can be seen to invoke an implicit them.

(25) #Momguilt is real, but we deserve a break too. Be sure to take it #momlife [URL to blog post titled ‘resetting’]

The collectivisation device ‘we’ in the above, in conjunction with ‘too’ implies that there is another group of non-mothers who are getting the break that these mothers deserve. Collectivisation was also used in construing the shared complaint that mothers and not others are undertaking too much emotional labour and so is involved in the policing of scoping.

(26) Lets talk #selfcare and #momguilt for a minute. It is all too often we lose sight of ourselves as Moms. We take on the role of boo-boo kisser, butt wiper, laundry queen, maker of meals you…[link to an Instagram post]


ChatGPT Comments:

The authors once again blur the boundary between language and context, treating membership categorisation (a semantic resource) as if it were a contextual operation (“a scoping resource”). In doing so, they mislocate the level at which collectivisation is modelled.

In SFL terms, “we” and “us” are grammatical resources realising interpersonal meaning at the semantic stratum. The collectivisation they effect is a semantic construal of social relation, not a contextual operation of “scope.” To treat such linguistic instantiations as contextual “resources” is to collapse the distinction between language and culture (context) — precisely the slippage that Halliday’s stratified model was designed to prevent.

Further, the claim that “membership categorisation tends to be a scoping resource” treats reference to social identity as if it directly adjusted contextual scope rather than construing participants within a meaning potential. This erases the crucial semiotic mediation through which such categories enter into context in the first place.

The authors’ use of the term “policing of scoping” adds another layer of confusion. “Policing” is metaphorically social, but “scoping” is analytically contextual in their model — yet here, both are used to describe textual patterns of interpersonal meaning. This reveals an unacknowledged drift toward analysing language as if it were contextual behaviour, which again conflates strata. The linguistic phenomena (pronouns, evaluative lexis, implicature) are semantic; the “scope” they are said to “police” is not part of the language system at all, but a construct of the authors’ contextual metalanguage.

Finally, the authors’ interpretation that “we” implies an implicit “them” is not wrong at the semantic level — but to treat that implication as a contextual operation rather than a semantic alignment introduces conceptual noise. The inclusive/exclusive contrast operates within language; it does not constitute scoping at the contextual level. 

Monday, 13 October 2025

Collapsing Scope: From Semiotic Resource to Social Group

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 137):

As mentioned earlier, the most frequent hashtags co-occurring with #momguilt provide an overview of the kinds of groups that are explicitly convoked or sourced in the corpus, for instance 'working moms' in posts such as (23).

(23) Can we talk about #momguilt? Especially that particular bind #workingmoms put themselves in: guilty for not being with their kids AND guilty for not devoting enough energy to work...

In this post the hashtag #workingmoms enacts scoping as it collectivises this group as the target of negative judgement, reinforcing the 'particular bind' for which this post casts them as responsible. Background meanings about the so-called 'mommy wars' (Abetz & Moore, 2018) which set 'stay-at-home mothers' (SAHM) against 'working mothers' are relevant to this scoping. An example of a hashtag used to convoke this opposing group is #SAHM in (24).

(24) I'm only REALLY happy when my husband is home. The second he leaves I feel like I will never be happy again. I hate this. #MomGuilt #SAHM

We can imagine that a high-stakes reply to this post would be to suggest that the mother find employment, because of the way that it leverages previously scoped and arranged bonds from the shared cultural context.


ChatGPT Comments:

The central problem in this excerpt is that Doran, Martin & Zappavigna once again blur the boundary between language and context. They treat hashtags like #workingmoms and #SAHM as though they enact contextual processes—“scoping,” “convoking groups,” or “reinforcing binds”—rather than as linguistic tokens whose semantic selections realise contextual relations. This collapses the Hallidayan distinction between semantics (as the construal of context) and context (as the semiotic potential realised through semantics).

By attributing contextual agency directly to the hashtags—claiming that #workingmoms “enacts scoping” or “collectivises a group”—the authors treat linguistic form as though it directly manipulates the social order. In the canonical model, however, this is a realisation relation: the hashtag realises a semantic construal of alignment, identification, or judgement within a field of discourse. It does not perform the contextual process itself.

The conceptual slippage is further revealed in their statement that “background meanings about the so-called ‘mommy wars’ … are relevant to this scoping.” Here, the ‘background meanings’ (that is, contextual semiotic potential) are treated as already arranged resources that language merely “leverages.” This reverses the dependency: it is through language that these contextual potentials are activated, instantiated, and made meaningfully relevant. Without that construal, there is no “background meaning” to leverage.

Finally, the speculative gesture—“we can imagine that a high-stakes reply to this post would be…”—reveals an even deeper confusion: they are analysing not actual social meaning but their own hypothetical construals as though these were features of the corpus. This imports the analyst’s imagination into the data without reflexive acknowledgement, reinforcing the illusion that “shared cultural context” exists independently of its linguistic construal.

In short, the authors mislocate meaning-making: instead of analysing how language realises contextual meaning, they describe language as doing contextual work directly, thereby erasing the stratification on which systemic functional linguistics depends.

Sunday, 12 October 2025

Blurring the Boundary Between Context and Text Once More

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 137):

Since the corpus consisted of posts about experiences of guilt, the people and groups experiencing guilt or judging others as guilty are pertinent to tuning. The choice of the source tends to operate in the service of scoping in the corpus. For example, as we have seen mothers reject themselves through negative self-judgement throughout the corpus (e.g. 'moms' in (21)), with the most common source of such negative self-judgement being the author themselves (e.g. 'I' in (22).

(21) Do any other #moms feel guilty about just vegging and watching tv while their kid naps? #momguilt #momlife #motherhood #shouldibedoingsomethingproductive

(22) I feel like the worst parent in the world listening to my kid sniff with snot in their nose. #momguilt #momlife #sickbaby


ChatGPT Comments:

This paragraph once again exposes a recurrent conceptual confusion in the authors’ model — namely, the conflation of contextual variables with linguistic realisations. Scoping and tuning are presented as contextual (tenor-level) systems, yet the examples offered are entirely linguistic: pronouns (“I,” “moms”), appraisal lexis (“worst parent”), and hashtags. These are all resources of the discourse semantic system of APPRAISAL, not contextual categories.

By treating linguistic patterns as contextual systems, the authors collapse the crucial Hallidayan distinction between context (the culture as semiotic system) and language (the realisation of that potential). The passage thus fails to maintain the semiotic stratification that underpins systemic functional theory: field, tenor, and mode should be realised by semantics, not constituted by it.

The result is a descriptive circularity — “scope” appears both as context and as language realisation, with no theoretical cut between the two. What should have been a reflection on how context is construed through linguistic resources becomes instead a blurred fusion of strata.

Saturday, 11 October 2025

Scaling Belonging: The Semiotic Gradient of Scope

Doran, Martin & Zappavigna (2025: 136):

Tuning may be adjusted by expanding or restricting the range of individual personae or groups to whom a particular meaning is applicable. In the case of our corpus, we have to a certain extent built scoping into our selection criteria for constructing the corpus since the #momguilt hashtag broadly concerns mothers. Scoping can involve both expansion and contraction in terms of the group or personae relevant to the meaning in play. For instance, embracing a whole community through choices in pronominal grammar is a choice to enlarge scope.

(17) We all have it. And it's never easy #momguilt [link to an article about 'mom guilt'] #parenting #momlife #guilt

(18) Moms, if this isn’t all of us on some level I don’t know what is. We try to do it all because the #momguilt tells us we have to ...but God didn’t make us to live like that. It takes a village! Walk alongside each other and lift each other up!

At the same time various resources for identifying participants can reduce the scope to the level of individuals.

(19) Telling my four babies goodbye yesterday. Enjoying some me time, but I miss them when I’m away. #momguilt

Scope can also be narrowed down to particular kinds of groups. For instance, in (20) the clients who experience guilt are subspecified as mothers in particular.

(20) #Guilt is such a common emotion from my anxiety clients, particularly moms. #momguilt

While the distinction between whole communities and individuals is the most obvious case, social relations are very complex. Within communities there will be different arrays of subgroups, and groups which span multiple communities. There are different ways of 'dog whistling' with reference to these groups without naming them or addressing them directly.



ChatGPT Comments:

While the authors frame SCOPE as a tenor-level system—a feature of context governing the range of personae and communities relevant to a meaning—the examples they provide consistently conflate context with linguistic instantiation. Pronouns, vocatives, and hashtags are treated as if they themselves are scope, rather than as realisations of an underlying contextual potential. This risks collapsing the analytic distinction between what constrains interpersonal meaning (tenor/context) and what realises it in discourse (language/semantics).

Furthermore, discussions of subgrouping, cross-community references, and subtle “dog-whistling” imply a linguistic enactment of social reach, yet are presented as if they define the system itself. In SFL terms, tenor sets the potential scope, but the authors’ examples demonstrate textual realisation, not the systemic contextual resource. Without a clear separation, the TUNING system risks being misread as a description of discourse rather than a description of social context.